The Skull Ring

The Skull Ring is a quest given by the Island Outfitter. He will ask to find the Skull Ring and return it to him.

Walkthrough
To start this quest, speak to the Island Outfitter and ask about his special inventory:You can then offer to help:Finally, ask about the secret order:The Island Outfitter will give you the Order of the Night Hood and the Order of the Night Robes. Now, you need to find the Innkeeper. Remember to wear the disguise or else you'll not be able to ask about the ring:The Skull Ring can be found in Gold Pirate Chest located inside the pirate stronghold on Pirate King Settlement islands. Once you found it, you can choose to return it either to the Island Outfitter or the Innkeeper. The rewards will differ depending on who you choose.

Rewards
If you choose the Island Outfitter, he will give you the Silver Cloak, Blacktooth's Helm and Blacktooth's Chestplate.If you choose the Innkeeper, he will give you the High Priest's Staff, the High Priest's Hood and Robe.