Talk:Helping The Innkeeper/@comment-25012824-20160215163717/@comment-8477851-20160217165500

You will most likely need to look for a new island if you have already looted the chest on the given one. The only possibility of being able to use the same island is if there was a second unopened chest. To my knowledge you just need to find the type of chest listed. It shouldn't matter if it's on a piratr island or not. (I.e. another place a chest can be found is on a old pirate ship that hasn't been repaired.