Talk:The Dark Guardian/@comment-73.40.236.106-20150701210012

Is it possible to fight this guy more than once? I had 2 petrified hearts, used one and fought the Guardian, and now when I try to use the other, I get that "Now is not the time to sacrifice the heart" message. Do I need to find an altar on another island, maybe?

The reason I want to fight him again is because he didn't drop the Ceremonial Mace the first time. I want that mace, darnit!